Homemade Hot Chocolate with Mix-ins
Fun Homemade Hot Chocolate with Mix-ins makes a cozy addition to the holiday season. Creamy hot chocolate made with milk, cocoa powder and sugar. Serve with flavor mix-ins and pair with chocolatey biscuits.
November officially marks the holiday season for me. It’s the time of year when fall recipes like Butter Pecan Cake are in full effect—comforting, cozy and decadent. Thanksgiving is no exception for enjoying these delicious foods. Every year I’ve shared this holiday with my parents and family. A recent new tradition I’ve enjoyed as an adult is Friendsgiving.
This is an excuse to have an additional grand meal with those you care about, before or after the official holiday. Last year’s Friendsgiving was my first attempt at cooking a whole brined turkey. It was surprising success and most likely will become a new tradition. Another fun tradition I’m looking forward is DIY Hot Chocolate Mix-ins, made with homemade hot chocolate.
This hot chocolate recipe is simple as heating milk, cocoa powder and sugar. For a richer, creamier hot chocolate, substitute some half-and-half. Hot chocolate is of course wonderful on it’s own, but even better enjoyed with flavor mix-ins.
Some of my favorites are any combination of candied orange peel or fresh orange zest, vanilla extract, cayenne powder, black pepper and sea salt. You can also add candied ginger, caramel, peppermint or almond extract to name a few.
Try DIY Hot Chocolate Mix-ins during your next Friendsgiving. Mine can’t come soon enough and I wish you a fun and flavorful holiday season.

This Hot chocolate can be enjoyed as a comforting drink for breakfast or as a delightful afternoon treat, perfect pairing with Chocolate Breakfast Bread in the morning or snacks like Chocolate Espresso Brownies later in the day.
More holiday recipes you might like:
- Cranberry Maple Blondies
- Holiday Themed Eggnog Waffles
- Apple Cider Cheesecake
- Pumpkin Cheese Ball
- Creamy Mashed Potatoes
- Chocolate Peppermint Cookies
- Kahlua Coffee Chocolate Fudge Cake
Homemade Hot Chocolate with Mix-ins
Ingredients
- 4 cups whole milk to make creamier, replace some with half-and-half
- ¾ cup cocoa powder
- 6 tablespoons granulated sugar
- Desired flavor mix-ins below
Instructions
- Whisk together milk/half-and-half, cocoa powder, and sugar in a large sauce pan over medium heat (use more or less sugar depending on how sweet you prefer).
- Stir constantly and heat until warm, but remove before boiling.
- Pour into mugs and stir in the desired amount of mix-ins, such as candied orange peel, fresh orange zest, candied ginger, vanilla extract, cinnamon, cayenne powder, black pepper, sea salt, caramel, peppermint, or almond extract.
If anything, you’ve convinced me to look for TimTam at my local Target!
I love a good hot chocolate so I am going to try this. Maybe add a little ginger or almond extract… Great idea
Yay for Friendsgiving! I have had too many of those, and am super happy I will be home with my family this year.
I love drinking hot chocolate! Thanks for sharing this recipe, looks pretty easy to make and tasty!